PORTAGE COUNTY | Zuchowski Supporters in Turmoil Over Public Record Law Enforcement
![]()
PORTAGE COUNTY — The comment section under the Fostoria Free Press’s November 12 pre-litigation notice post has turned into a running argument over Sheriff Bruce D. Zuchowski, with his supporters on the defensive as the Portage County Sheriff’s Office faces a public records fight under Ohio Revised Code 149.43.
The post, announcing that a combined pre-suit complaint was sent to the sheriff’s office by certified mail over the Free Press’s September 4 and October 5 public records requests, has drawn more than 130 comments and replies. The largest threads did not form under criticism of the sheriff — they formed under praise for him. A comment calling Zuchowski “an excellent sheriff” drew 24 replies, a pledge to “vote for him every time just because of all you haters” drew 12 replies, and a simple “Ill vote for him again” drew 9 more, as supporters and critics argued back and forth underneath each one.
Supporters backed the sheriff in plain terms — “Backing him 100%,” “He’s America’s Sheriff,” and promises to vote for him again — and several turned their fire on the Free Press and on Will Lane instead, asking where the paper was when Lane was accused in the Kalahari security guard incident and calling Lane a strangler. Others attacked the messenger directly, asking if the Free Press is “just that dude who is obsessed with the sheriff,” demanding to know what a Fostoria paper has to do with Portage County, and asking how to get a “random hypothetical” sheriff off their timeline.
That jurisdictional complaint was answered in the thread itself: anyone can request public records anywhere in the United States, and transparency is the right of the people.
Other supporters worked the details rather than the headline. One argued the Ohio Revised Code nowhere requires records to be produced within 3 days — a point the Free Press conceded in its reply, noting the 3 days was the deadline in its own pre-litigation notice, while ORC 149.43 requires records to be promptly prepared and provided within a reasonable period of time, and a request filed September 4 is still unfilled in November.
Running underneath the defense was open turmoil in the county itself. Critics of the sheriff outnumbered his defenders among the top-level comments, calling the office corrupt, thanking the Free Press for “fighting this fight,” saying Portage County can do better, and vowing never to vote for Zuchowski again because, in one commenter’s words, “they don’t follow ORC codes and don’t follow the laws.” One commenter asked what happens if a report was falsified, claiming the sheriff admitted to it on the phone — an allegation made in the comments, not established by the post. Still others were simply confused, asking what the notice is about, what is going on, and whether a court-appointed mediator would be a conflict of interest.
The picture the comments paint is not a county rallying around its sheriff. It is a split county arguing with itself — a loyal base pledging its votes louder than ever, surrounded by residents calling the sheriff’s office corrupt, questioning its handling of records, and thanking an out-of-county newspaper for forcing the issue into the open.
The underlying dispute remains unresolved: the Free Press’s pre-litigation notice gave the sheriff’s office 3 days to comply, with failure to comply set to meet the Ohio Supreme Court’s requirements for an original action requesting a writ of mandamus, with mediation the normal next step if the office still does not comply.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!