Fostoria Father Charged with Murder After Infant’s Death Attributed to Abuse

FOSTORIA – On February 11, 2025, at around 11:46 AM, Fostoria Police and EMS responded to a call at 1521 N. Countyline St, Fostoria, Ohio, regarding an unresponsive infant. Upon arrival, first responders attempted life-saving measures before transporting the 4-month-old to Fostoria ProMedica Hospital where the child was later pronounced dead.

Investigations by Fostoria Detectives and Wood County Children Services revealed that the infant’s death was due to trauma and abuse, not natural or accidental causes. The father, Joseph D. Bonito, aged 24, was identified as the perpetrator after further interviews and investigation.

He has been charged with Murder under Ohio Revised Code 2903.02(B) and Endangering Children under ORC 2919.22 (B)(1)(E)(d). Bonito is currently detained at the Wood County Jail without bond, pending his initial court appearance. The case remains under investigation.

###FOSTORIA POLICE PRESS RELEASE###
On Tuesday, February 11th, 2025, at approximately 11:46 AM, The Fostoria Police Department and Fostoria EMS responded to 1521 N. Countyline St, Fostoria, Wood County Ohio, for the report of an unresponsive infant. Once Fostoria First Responders arrived on scene, lifesaving actions were implemented, and the infant was then immediately transported to the Fostoria ProMedica Hospital for further medical aid. Unfortunately, the 4-month-old child was later pronounced deceased.While investigating the incident, Fostoria Detectives and Wood County Children Services Investigators were able to determine the infant’s death was not of natural causes or accidental, and that the child had sustained injuries that were consistent with trauma and abuse. Through further interviews and investigation, detectives and investigators were able to determine the father, Joseph D. Bonito, 24 YOA, had purposefully injured the infant, which lead to the death. At this time, Mr. Bonito has been charged with Murder, ORC 2903.02(B) and Endangering Children, ORC 2919.22 (B)(1)(E)(d). Mr. Bonito is currently being held in the Wood County Jail with no bond, awaiting his initial court appearance. The incident remains under investigation. Gabe WedgeChief of PoliceFostoria Police Department

Drug Bust Uncovers Child Endangerment in Flat Rock, OH: Meth, Tools & Firearms Seized

FLAT ROCK, SENECA COUNTY, OH –  A coordinated effort by the Seneca County Drug Task Force-METRICH, Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, and Sandusky County Drug Task Force executed a search warrant at 7715 N. Co. Road 29. The search, authorized by Judge Damon Alt from Seneca County Common Pleas Court, targeted the residence of 36-year-old Paul Buchanan.
During the search, authorities seized suspected methamphetamine, criminal tools, and firearms. The investigation is ongoing with pending charges of Illegal Possession of Methamphetamine and Possession of Criminal Tools against the residents.
Upon entering the home, law enforcement found two children living in dire conditions characterized by unhygienic and unsafe environments, including exposure to dangerous materials and insect infestations. Seneca County Children Services was immediately notified, and the children were removed from the home for their safety. Sheriff Fredrick W. Stevens expressed relief at both the drug seizure and the rescue of the children from their hazardous living situation.

Seneca County Deputy Injured in 2nd Arrest of William R. Stevens

FLAT ROCK, OHIO | On Wednesday, February 5, 2025, after placing a $200,000.00 cash/asurety bond on a previous charge, William R. Stevens was released from the Seneca County Jail. Later this date, the Warsaw Police Department, in State of Indiana, filed for an arrest warrant for Stevens. Their agency contacted the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office to request assistance to locate and apprehend Stevens. The Seneca County Sheriff’s office received a nationwide warrant out of the State of Indiana for Unlawful Sexual Misconduct with a Minor, a Felony of the Fourth Degree.

Seneca County Sheriff’s Office Deputies located Stevens at the Seneca County Probation Office and he was again placed into custody pursuant to the out of state arrest warrant. While being placed under arrest, the defendant, Stevens, physically attacked the Deputy knocking him to the ground and assaulting him. Stevens attempted to flee the scene but was apprehended.

Arrested was William R. Stevens, 46 YOA, for the out of state arrest warrant-Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor, a Felony of the fourth degree. Also additional charges of Felonious Assault on a Peace Officer, a Felony of the First Degree and Obstructing Official Business, a Felony of the Fifth Degree. He is presently being held at the Seneca County Jail upon further prosecution.

“My Deputy was transported to Tiffin Mercy Hospital and he was treated for his injuries. I am pleased to hear that he was eventually able to go home to his family!” Sheriff Fredrick W. Stevens.

Flat Rock, Ohio Man Arrested for Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor

William R. Stevens, 46, of Flat Rock, Ohio, was arrested for Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor following an investigation led by the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office. Other agencies involved were the FBI, and the Ottawa County Crime Task Force (METRICH). Law enfrocement siezed electronic devices and other evidence related to the alleged sexual assault of a juvenile.

Sheriff Fredrick W. Stevens aplauded the effort between federal and state agencies for ensuring the safety of the community. William remains in the Seneca County Jail pending further prosecution.

###PRESS RELEASE###

After receiving a report of an alleged sexual assault involving a juvenile at the residence located at 15960 Water Street, Flat Rock, Ohio 44828, on Monday, February 03, 2025, the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, along with several other Law Enforcement Agencies executed multiple search warrants to attempt to retrieve evidence related to the initial complaint.

William R. Stevens, 46 YOA, for Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a MinorPhoto bySeneca County Sheriffs Office

Detectives from the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office received information from Special Agents with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Cleveland Field Office, Toledo Resident Agency, which started the investigation into the allegation.Upon further investigation and obtaining additional information, a search warrant and arrest warrant were obtained for the owner of the Flat Rock residence. The search warrant signed by Judge Damon Alt of the Seneca County Common Pleas Court led to the confiscation of additional evidence believed to be related to the sexual assault investigation.

Additional search warrants were also obtained for several electronic devices related to the investigation. Additional Special Agents and Task Force Officers from the FBI Cleveland Field Office-Toledo Resident Agency, the Ottawa County Crime Task Force, the Seneca County Drug Task Force – METRICH Enforcement Unit, Ottawa County Crime Task Force Canine Unit, and the multi-juris Seneca County Special Response Team were all utilized to execute the search warrant on the residence safely and effectively. Arrested was William R. Stevens, 46 YOA, for Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor, a Felony of the Third degree.

He is presently being held at the Seneca County Jail upon further prosecution.“Based on all the facts and circumstances of this entire investigation, I truly believe that Seneca County is safer this evening because this individual is off our streets. The diligent work and collaboration between numerous Federal and State Law Enforcement Agencies was instrumental to the success of this investigation!”

Sheriff Fredrick W. Stevens.

Tiffin Police Arrest Local Man for Sharing Child Exploitation Material via BitTorrent

January 23, 2025

TIFFIN A covert online investigation led by Detective Eric England of the Tiffin Police Department’s Criminal Division has resulted in the arrest of 46-year-old Mick J. Okonski. The investigation, conducted with the support of multiple law enforcement agencies, uncovered the sharing of child sexual exploitation material via the peer-to-peer file-sharing protocol BitTorrent.

Earlier today, authorities executed a search warrant at a residence in the 700 block of S. Washington St. in Tiffin, Ohio. Mr. Okonski admitted to both downloading and sharing the illicit material and was taken into custody. He is currently being held at the Seneca County Jail pending his arraignment.

Mr. Okonski faces charges of Pandering Obscenity Involving a Minor, a second-degree felony that carries a maximum penalty of eight years in prison and/or a $15,000 fine. Authorities have indicated that additional charges may be filed as the investigation continues and further evidence is analyzed.

The successful conclusion of this investigation was made possible through the collaborative efforts of the METRICH Task Force, the FBI Crimes Against Children Task Force, the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, the Ohio Investigative Unit, and the Ottawa County Sheriff’s Office. Their combined expertise and support were instrumental in bringing this case to a resolution.

Chief Pauly of the Tiffin Police Department expressed his gratitude to Detective England and the Criminal Division for their tireless dedication. He also extended appreciation to the assisting agencies for their unwavering commitment to protecting the community.

“The safety and well-being of our children remain our top priority,” said Chief Pauly. “We will continue to work diligently to hold offenders accountable and ensure justice is served.”

The Tiffin Police Department encourages anyone with information related to child exploitation to report it to local authorities or through national hotlines.

For further updates on this case, stay tuned to official law enforcement communications and local news outlets.

 

Columbus, OH felon captured after multi-county pursuit | Hancock & Wyandot

FINDLAY, Ohio (WTVG) – A Columbus man was taken into custody after allegedly leading law enforcement on a high-speed pursuit from Hancock County into Wyandot County.

On January 22 at approximately 1:30 p.m., deputies from the Hancock County Sheriff’s Office attempted to pull over a driver who had two active warrants. The driver refused to stop, initiating a pursuit.

The chase proceeded southbound on Blanchard Avenue in Findlay, continuing onto State Route 37, then southbound on State Route 15 before merging onto U.S. 23.

Authorities reported that the driver eventually came to a stop about one mile north of State Highway 199 in Wyandot County. He exited the vehicle and surrendered to law enforcement without further incident.

The pursuit covered a distance of 28 miles over 20 minutes, reaching speeds as high as 115 mph.

The driver, identified as Chaz Holley of Columbus, was taken to the Hancock County Justice Center. He faces charges of Failure to Comply and Driving Under Suspension.

In addition to the current charges, Holley is being held on an outstanding warrant from Franklin County for multiple offenses, including Failure to Appear for Abduction, Tampering with Evidence, Possession of Drugs, Having Weapons Under Disability, Improper Handling of a Firearm, Failure to Comply, and Receiving Stolen Property. He also has a separate warrant from the Columbus Police Department for Domestic Violence.

Former Marblehead Police Officer Convicted of 124 Unauthorized OHLEG Database Searches to Investigate Ex Gf.

OTTAWA COUNTY, Ohio — A Village of Marblehead police officer has been convicted of unauthorized use of a law enforcement database for personal reasons. Michael Scherer pleaded guilty on Friday in Ottawa County Common Pleas Court to 26 counts of unauthorized use of the Ohio Law Enforcement Gateway (OHLEG), all fifth-degree felonies. His sentencing is scheduled for March 7.

According to his personnel records, Marblehead Police Chief Kenn Thellman filed a formal complaint against Scherer on July 11, 2024, citing repeated misuse of OHLEG over a two-year period, a violation of Ohio law. The investigation into Scherer’s misconduct began when he applied for a position with the Bowling Green Police Department (BGPD).

During the BGPD background investigation, conducted between June 24 and July 2, Chief Tony Hetrick interviewed Scherer and several of his references. One former roommate and ex-girlfriend described Scherer as “neither honest nor reliable” and expressed fear of him as a police officer. She alleged that Scherer ran license plate checks through OHLEG while off duty, targeting her child’s father, her neighbors, and even vehicles that committed traffic violations in his presence. She also claimed he conducted searches at his mother’s request.

Chief Thellman was notified of these findings and officially lodged the complaint. Additionally, on July 12, Thellman reprimanded Scherer for unrelated incidents, including spending excessive on-duty hours at Bay Point Resort. Complaints indicated Scherer’s cruiser was parked on Bay Point Boulevard for over five hours and that he attended a garage party until after 4 a.m., even allowing an unidentified female into his patrol car. Thellman prohibited Scherer from socializing at Bay Point while on duty and required the return of his access card.

Further complaints included Marblehead Mayor John Starcher’s report that Scherer locked his dog inside the council meeting room unattended—an action Thellman firmly stated would not be tolerated again.

An audit conducted on Scherer’s OHLEG account confirmed over 124 unauthorized searches during off-duty hours across two years. As a result, Scherer was suspended on July 18, 2024, pending a mayoral review and subsequently terminated from the Marblehead Police Department on July 22, 2024.

Scherer’s employment history reveals a pattern of concerning behavior. He joined the Toledo Police Department in 2018 but resigned in December 2019 amid an internal investigation prompted by a complaint from the Oregon city prosecutor. The investigation recommended charges of “abuse of authority” and “conduct unbecoming an officer.” Scherer resigned before facing a hearing.

From October 2020 to June 2021, Scherer worked part-time for the Woodville Police Department. Woodville Police Chief Steve Gilkerson noted that although Scherer had previously resigned from Toledo PD under investigation, he was given an opportunity with Woodville PD. However, Scherer reportedly misled dispatchers during an incident where he drove a female to a hotel near Perrysburg or Rossford, falsely claiming he was handling equipment in Genoa. Scherer resigned from Woodville PD just before the department launched its own internal investigation, avoiding possible termination.

Scherer claimed he left Woodville PD to accept a position with the Marblehead Police Department.

His conviction now closes a troubling chapter in his law enforcement career, raising questions about oversight and accountability within local police departments.

THREAT by Benito Thebeau Has Been Sent to Fulton County Sheriff’s Office & Prosecutor’s Office

On January 10, 2025, Benito Thebeau issued a severe and alarming threat through a private message, displaying reckless and dangerous behavior. Thebeau’s message included an explicit warning suggesting violent retaliation, accompanied by a photograph of a firearm and a group image of a military squad. His statement, “just saying you shoot my dog just cause it’s loose you better hope you and your ar are cq trained and have lvl 4 plates fuck boy,” clearly conveyed a violent threat of bodily harm.

This threat has been formally reported to the Fulton County Sheriff’s Office and the Fulton County Prosecutor’s Office. A detailed email was sent, including screenshots of Benito Thebeau’s threatening message and accompanying images. Due to the serious nature of the threat, increased security measures are being implemented to ensure the safety of the recipient and their family.

Such behavior is not only irresponsible but also illegal. Threats of violence, particularly those involving firearms, are taken very seriously by law enforcement. Benito Thebeau’s actions are under review, and appropriate legal steps will be pursued to address this matter and protect those targeted by his threats.

Law enforcement authorities have been urged to investigate this threat thoroughly and take any necessary actions to ensure public safety. This incident serves as a reminder that threats of violence carry significant legal consequences and will not be tolerated under any circumstances.

 

Morgan Geyser Granted Conditional Release in Slender Man Stabbing Case

Waukesha, WI — Morgan Geyser, one of the two girls convicted in the infamous 2014 Slender Man stabbing, has been granted conditional release from a Wisconsin mental health facility, marking a significant development in the decade-old case that shocked the nation.

On Thursday, Waukesha County Circuit Judge Michael Bohren signed the order for Geyser’s supervised release. The Wisconsin Department of Health Services has been tasked with developing a detailed plan for her transition within the next 60 days. Until the plan is finalized, Geyser will remain at the Winnebago Mental Health Institute before moving to a group home under supervision.

Geyser, now 22, was only 12 when she and her friend, Anissa Weier, lured their classmate Payton Leutner into the woods and stabbed her 19 times in a disturbing attempt to appease the fictional internet character Slender Man. Leutner miraculously survived the brutal attack, despite sustaining life-threatening injuries.

Both Geyser and Weier were charged in adult court with first-degree attempted intentional homicide. Geyser was found guilty but was declared not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect and sentenced to up to 40 years in a psychiatric facility. Weier, who pleaded guilty to a lesser charge, was sentenced to up to 25 years but was granted supervised release in 2021 at the age of 19.

The decision to release Geyser comes after testimonies from three psychologists who have closely monitored her progress. Dr. Brooke Lundbohm, testifying via Zoom, supported Geyser’s petition for release, stating, “I don’t think she currently poses a significant risk of substantial harm to herself, others, or to property damage.”

Lundbohm noted Geyser’s marked improvement in mental health since a suicide attempt in 2021. Although Geyser still struggles with self-criticism and low self-esteem, she has been described as bright and articulate. Psychologist Kenneth Robbins echoed these sentiments, highlighting Geyser’s aspirations to become a librarian and eventually a therapist for individuals struggling with substance abuse.

Robbins confirmed that Geyser, once diagnosed with schizophrenia, has not shown psychotic symptoms in over two years and has been successfully weaned off antipsychotic medications. However, she continues to manage post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, and autism.

Dr. Deborah Collins also testified, affirming that Geyser understands the conditions of her release, including residing in a group home and wearing an ankle monitor. Collins stated, “She recognizes that she would be subject to a whole host of expectations and rules, and what could happen if she violated those.”

The victim’s family remains cautious about Geyser’s release. Payton Leutner’s mother, Stacie Leutner, expressed her concerns in a statement: “Morgan Geyser has withdrawn her request to be released twice. More recently, her request was denied. We are confident that the judicial system will make a decision that will ensure the community, and my daughter remain safe.”

Geyser’s previous request for release was denied in April 2024, but this ruling marks a turning point in her path toward reintegration into society. The next two months will be critical as officials finalize the conditions of her supervised release.

The Slender Man stabbing continues to be a chilling reminder of how fictional narratives can influence real-world violence. The case remains one of the most disturbing in recent memory, sparking ongoing discussions about mental health, internet influence, and juvenile justice.

 

METRICH Drug Unit Executes Search Warrant in Fostoria

 

On January 6, 2025, the Seneca County Drug Task Force-METRICH, with assistance from the Fostoria Police Department and the Hancock County Drug Task Force, executed a search warrant at 1240 N. Countyline St. in Fostoria.

As a result, suspected crack cocaine, LSD, drug paraphernalia, and a sawed-off shotgun were seized. Two individuals, Tristin Conley (23) and Christopher Pryor (32), were arrested and are currently being held in the Seneca County Jail, with additional charges pending.

Chief Gabriel Wedge of the Fostoria Police Department stated, “Crack cocaine abuse has negatively impacted our community for years. This investigation successfully shut down a dangerous operation and removed another firearm from criminal hands.”

Community members are encouraged to report suspicious activity to the METRICH Crime Hotline at 419-443-0463 ext. 1140. Together, we can keep our neighborhoods safe!

#Fostoria #SenecaCounty #METRICH #CommunitySafety