City of Fostoria Botches 2025 Tree Lighting Ceremony, Called Pathetic & a Joke

FOSTORIA | On December 5th 2025 the City of Fostoria hosted their annual Christmas Tree Lighting at the city building. The coffee shop was closed and the attendees made the best of what they we’re given. Many community members called the event pathetic and a joke, while leaving them wondering who has complained enough to reduce Christmas cheer in Fostoria?

The Decline in Effort From 2023 – 2025

 

No More Christmas Cards Since 2023

The reason why Christmas Cards ended was do to Karens complaining that they looked bad. To make matters more petty, some business owners went into an uproar because they were not happy with their card next to a competing business. Sad…

 

Festive Grinch dressed as Santa poses near decorated Christmas tree with gifts, holiday spirits.

 

Possible Solutions/Remediations:

  1. Better advertising for the event.
  2. A reasonable date & time.
  3. Actual festivities and activities for the public.
  4. A Coffee shop that says open.
  5. Asking the community for donations for lights if there is a low budget.
  6. Ultimately, better leadership, a reasonable budget, and most importantly ‘Caring’!

2025 Fostoria Snow King Contest Now LIVE!

Snowflake with winter background, promoting community snow king event.

FOSTORIA | Since the City of Fostoria currently excludes men from their holiday crowning tradition I have decided to take it upon myself last minute to crown a local king in 2025!  Although this is common sense to do let’s make this fun and lead Fostoria to do the right thing in 2026.

Prize: $100 CASH, 1 Troy Oz Silver Bar, & a Deck of Gold Foil Playing Cards.
CONTEST RULES:
1. Must be 18 years or older and a Resident of Fostoria.
2. Must take your best “King” picture in the snow & post it on this video post!
3. Must share this post & tag at least 1 friend.
Contestant photos will be voted on via a social media poll for transparency. Poll will be posted December 20th.

Fostoria “Snow Queen” Only Sexist?

Editor/Publisher: Joshua Tolento, Tolento Media Group
Published November 25th, 2025

Imagine a “Men Only” Snow King Contest – Now Explain Why the Current One Isn’t Sexist

Every year, the city of Fostoria, Ohio, crowns a “Snow Queen” in a community celebration that draws hundreds of votes and plenty of local pride. On November 25, 2025, the Fostoria Review Times happily announced that Biola Villarreal had won the title for 2025, beating out two other female nominees in a vote that garnered an impressive 1,358 participants. The crowning ceremony is set for November 26 at the Fostoria Learning Center, and the public is invited.

It’s wholesome small-town Americana… except for one glaring detail: only women are eligible.

For decades, the Snow Queen contest has been exclusively female. Men are not nominated, do not appear on the ballot, and cannot win the crown. There is no male counterpart—no “Snow King,” no gender-neutral “Snow Monarch,” nothing. The event’s own press release casually refers to “the three women on this year’s ballot,” as if it’s self-evident that men need not apply.

Imagine the reverse.

Imagine if Fostoria announced an annual “Snow King” contest open only to men. Three male nominees. 1,358 votes cast. A big ceremony crowning the winner. And when someone asked, “Why can’t women participate?” the organizers shrugged and said, “It’s just always been the Snow King.”

Would that be called charming tradition? Or would every local news outlet, social media feed, and advocacy group instantly brand it sexist, exclusionary, and a relic of outdated gender roles?

Most readers would have no trouble answering that question. A men-only title in 2025 would be met with rightful criticism and demands for either inclusion or a parallel Snow Queen category. Yet when the exclusion runs in the opposite direction—when men are simply shut out year after year—it’s treated as perfectly normal, even celebrated.

That double standard is the problem.

No one is suggesting the Snow Queen title be abolished! Traditions can be wonderful. But fairness isn’t complicated: either open the contest to all genders (call the winner Snow Monarch, Snow Royalty, or keep the Queen title and let anyone compete), or create a balanced Snow King category alongside it. Anything less quietly tells half the population their gender disqualifies them from full participation in a civic celebration paid for and attended by the entire community.

Fostoria’s Snow Queen contest proved this year it can generate real enthusiasm—1,358 votes is remarkable turnout for a small city. Imagine how much more engagement there would be if every resident, regardless of sex, felt welcome to nominate or be nominated.

So here’s the simple question organizers—and the community—should ask themselves:

If Fostoria held an annual “Snow King” contest and explicitly barred women from the ballot, would you consider that sexist?

If the honest answer is yes, then it’s time to fix the imbalance in the opposite direction too.

Congratulations to Biola Villarreal on her well-earned crown! And here’s hoping next year’s ballot finally reflects the whole community it claims to represent.

City of Fostoria Awarded $100,000 Urban Forestry Grant!

### PRESS RELEASE ###

We are excited to share that the City of Fostoria has been awarded $100,000 from the Ohio Urban Forestry Division to continue strengthening and revitalizing our city’s urban forest.
Many of you know we previously received a $1 million American Forestry grant at the federal level. While that funding supported critical early phases of our overall Urban Forestry Program, this new state-level grant will allow us to move into Phase 3: Tree Planting and Establishment.

Where We Are in the Urban Forestry Program

Phase 1 – Public Tree Inventory & Risk Assessment

Completed by Davey Resource Group and funded through the American Forestry grant. This work provided a citywide evaluation of all public trees and identified hazardous or declining trees needing removal.

Phase 2 – Urban Forest Management & Master Planting Plan

Completed last week. This plan identifies all vacant planting sites throughout the city and recommends appropriate species for both replacement plantings and future canopy health.

Phase 3 – Tree Planting & Establishment (Now Funded!)

This new Urban Forestry grant will be focused on downtown Fostoria, specifically replacing all Callery pear trees, which are recognized as an invasive species. Many of our urban trees were planted at the same time decades ago, leading to many of them declining at the same time as well. Removing invasive or hazardous trees and replanting with healthy, diverse, and site-appropriate species will greatly improve the long-term health of our canopy.
What to Expect Downtown
Our Tree & Beautification Commission has been working diligently to select the right species for the right locations while considering storefront visibility, safety, root behavior, sidewalk impacts, and long-term maintenance.
In the coming weeks, we will begin delivering informational materials to downtown business owners and tenants. For now, please note:
➡️ All trees on Main Street from South Street to North Street will be removed and replaced as soon as possible.
️ Behind the Scenes
We are actively using TreeKeeper, our new tree-management software, to log calls, track work orders, and ensure our crews are addressing needs efficiently.
A big thank you to Botimer Tree Service, Ernie Russell Stump Removal, and our own City of Fostoria crews for their hard work in improving our urban forest.
Questions About a City Tree?
If you have a question about a tree in the boulevard in front of your home or if you notice a tree that may pose a hazard, please don’t hesitate to reach out. We’re committed to maintaining a safe, healthy, and sustainable urban canopy for generations to come.
Fostoria’s future is growing—literally! ✨

 

 

A financial audit request of ‘The Fostoria Sharing Kitchen’ has been filed with Ohio Attorney General

FOSTORIA, OH | A complaint has been filed with the Ohio Attorney General’s office requesting an Audit of The Fostoria Sharing Kitchen.

Whats going on?
1. Fostoria Sharing Kitchen said the building demolition located at 321 N Main St., Fostoria would start in about 30 days. This was posted 7 months ago.

2. There have been no social media posts updating the public on the status since August of 2025.

3. Local “press” continues to report on the status of this non-profit without any investigative journalism.

4. The Sharing Kitchen has been asked to show their bank statements & records multiple times by The Fostoria Free Press. In turn, they blocked our page on Facebook.

5. The Sharing Kitchen does not post any regular board meetings, minutes, agendas, etc. Another lack of transparency.

 

Holding Onto 321 N Main Street, a Bad Idea?

The Fostoria Sharing Kitchen’s building went neglected for decades. Between the asbestos, leaking roof, structure problems- The non-profit handed out cucumbers on July 28th, 2025. This was the last public post made on their Facebook page offering to provide food.

Negative Opinions About The Owners

Over the last 2 years people have reached out to provide their concerns about The Fostoria Sharing Kitchen and it’s current owners. Here are snippets of what some people have said:

“I am a president of a local non-profit, I spoke with the owners in the past and in my opinion They are not good people at all. They don’t care about anyone but themselves”

“Don’t trust the sharing kitchen”

“We offered them a place to operate out of for free and they turned it down”

Complaint Filed to Ohio Attorney General

FOSTORIA Restaurant weeks away from going out-of-business due to oversaturated Food Truck Market

FOSTORIA – I received the following email from a local restaurant owner that wishing to remain anonymous.

> Sent: Friday, November 14, 2025 at 4:32 pm
> From: “I have to hide my identity” <userunknown44830@mail.com>
> To: Fostoriafreepress@gmail.com
> Subject: Inquiry
>
> Greetings,
>
> I am writing to you privately and anonymously as I fear I will be attacked on the internet and my business may be “cancelled”
>
> I own a brick and mortar restaurant in Fostoria, and I am concerned regarding all the food trucks that are out in town every single day. On average 4-5 trucks are out daily, a few local trucks but mainly out of town trucks, some who are not even “legal” to operate.
>
> I am asking that you look into this and see why this occurring? Fostoria is a great community, and food trucks are fun, different and exciting but we are opening our doors to outsiders who do not contribute to our community, folks are rushing to these trucks and flat out ignoring the brick and mortars.
>
> The community has to support what they have or they will see closures, I know for mine we are weeks away from possibly closing. And when the dust settles the community will have food trucks until they decide another town is better for them then our community will have nothing.
>
>
> Unknown”

One Fostoria Resident Steps Up: Kamiah’s Kitchen Brings Free Food and Essentials

By Independent Contributor Fostoria, Ohio – November 17, 2025

FOSTORIA, OH – In a town where need doesn’t wait for bureaucracy, one local woman has taken matters into her own hands. Kamiah Young, a longtime Fostoria resident, has transformed her front lawn and sidewalk into Kamiah’s Kitchen – a grassroots, no-questions-asked giveaway spot offering canned goods, non-perishable food, household items, clothing, sub sandwiches, soups, egg sandwiches, and other essentials completely free to anyone who needs them.

Every day that weather allows, tables and boxes appear outside her home stocked with donations from community members and local businesses. Neighbors stop by on foot, by car, or on bikes to pick up what they need – no forms, no appointments, no judgment.”I saw people struggling, and I couldn’t just sit by,” Kamiah shared in recent social media updates. “If I have it to give, it’s there for whoever needs it. This community raised me, and now it’s my turn to give back the best way I know how.”

Meanwhile, Questions Continue About the Sharing Kitchen of Fostoria

While Kamiah’s Kitchen fills an urgent gap with visible daily impact, the town’s official nonprofit food assistance organization – The Sharing Kitchen of Fostoria (EIN: 34-1661501) – has faced growing community scrutiny for its lack of activity despite holding substantial financial resources.

Established in 1991 as a 501(c)(3) food bank and pantry, the Sharing Kitchen once served hot meals and distributed food to those in need. However, in recent years, residents report little to no public distribution or community events.

Financial Information for The Sharing Kitchen of Fostoria (EIN: 34-1661501) from the Newly Released 2023 Form 990 (tax year ending December 31, 2023)

  • Total revenue: $56,481
    • Contributions, gifts, and grants: $47,239
    • Investment income (interest, dividends, etc.): $9,242
  • Total expenses: $26,920 (almost entirely classified as “program service expenses,” though Part III Statement of Program Service Accomplishments remains completely blank — no description of any services provided)
  • Net increase in assets for 2023: $29,561
  • Total net assets / fund balance at beginning of 2023: $786,155
  • Total net assets / fund balance at end of 2023: $815,716
  • Primary assets:
    • Land, building, and equipment (net of depreciation): $30,000
    • Publicly traded securities / savings & temporary cash investments: $730,280 (up from $708,868 the prior year)
    • Cash (non-interest-bearing): $46,436
  • No salaries, no rent, no utilities, no food purchases, no grants to others, and no other significant program-related spending listed beyond the broad $26,920 bucket.

Current Projection (as of November 17, 2025)

Assuming the same conservative pattern seen in recent years (≈3% average annual growth from interest/dividends plus modest donations minus very low expenses), the organization’s net assets are now likely in the range of $865,000 – $890,000 — well above the $800,000 community estimate that was circulating before this return became public.

In short: The Sharing Kitchen of Fostoria ended 2023 with $815,716 in net assets (mostly in cash and investments), continues to receive donations and earn investment income, spends only a small fraction each year, and still provides no public description of any active food-distribution or community-support programs on its 2023 Form 990.

The organization’s official Facebook page shows virtually no activity in years, with no recent posts about distributions, volunteer opportunities, or community meals. Local coverage by the Fostoria Free Press has repeatedly highlighted these concerns, questioning why a nonprofit with such resources appears dormant while food insecurity remains a daily reality for many residents.

The building located at 321 N Main St. Fostoria was expected to be demolished 6 months ago. It is November 17th & the building is still up. Many people have commented on The Fostoria Sharing Kitchen’s Post receiving zero response.

Tragic Infant Death in Fostoria: Joseph Bonito’s Arrest, Guilty Plea, and 25-Year Prison Sentence

Incident Overview

On February 11, 2025, just before noon, officers from the Fostoria Police Department and emergency medical personnel responded to a report of an unresponsive 4-month-old infant at a residence in the 1500 block of North Countyline Street in Fostoria, Ohio. The father, Joseph D. Bonito (then 24 years old), made the 911 call, reporting that he had last checked on his son, Carson J. Bonito, about three hours earlier to feed him, but the child now appeared “white” and unresponsive. First responders performed lifesaving measures and transported the infant to Fostoria ProMedica Hospital, where he was pronounced dead shortly after arrival. The child’s mother was at work at the time, and police noted this was not the first instance of abuse.

Investigators from the Fostoria Police Department and Wood County Children Services determined the death was not natural or accidental, with injuries consistent with trauma and abuse. Bonito admitted to shaking and squeezing the infant, which caused the fatal injuries. Bonito had no prior record with Fostoria police.

Arrest and Charges

Bonito was arrested on February 11, 2025, initially charged with murder and child endangering. He was held without bond in Wood County Jail. A Wood County grand jury indicted him on February 19, 2025, on charges of murder (unclassified felony), endangering children (second-degree felony), and felonious assault (second-degree felony). He was arraigned with bond set at $500,000, and a hearing was scheduled for April 14, 2025.

Plea and Sentencing

On October 6, 2025, Bonito pleaded guilty to amended charges: one count of involuntary manslaughter (first-degree felony), one count of child endangering (second-degree felony), and two counts of felonious assault (second-degree felonies). This was part of a plea deal with prosecutors. His defense attorney noted he had accepted responsibility and shown remorse. Bonito declined to address the court.

On November 3, 2025, Wood County Common Pleas Judge Mary “Molly” L. Mack sentenced Bonito to 25 to 31.5 years in prison: 11 to 16.5 years for manslaughter and 7 years each for the two assault charges, served consecutively. He was transferred from jail to prison that day.

Public Records and Released Materials

The Fostoria Police Department released the 911 call audio made by Bonito shortly after the arrest. No specific details were found on the release of body-worn camera footage, interrogation video/audio, photographs, or other materials in response to public records requests. However, the Law&Crime Network published detailed coverage of the case, including Bonito’s mugshot and background on the incident, suggesting they obtained at least some records (such as reports or photos) through their request or other means. No explicit confirmation of the request’s fulfillment status was located in public sources, but the widespread media reporting (including from WTOL, WTVG, Sentinel-Tribune, and others) indicates that key investigative details were made available to the press. The Fostoria Police Department’s website does not list any press releases or archives related to this case as of the latest available data.

Current Status

As of November 15, 2025, the case is closed following Bonito’s sentencing on November 3, 2025. He is serving his prison term in an Ohio state correctional facility. No appeals or further proceedings have been reported in public sources. No recent social media discussions (e.g., on X) were found mentioning updates beyond the sentencing.

Top 10 Most Recently Registered Active Non-Profits in Fostoria

Top 10 Most Recently Registered Active Non-Profits

(Ranked by filing/registration date, newest first)
Citizens for Fostoria – Sep 04, 2025 (Unincorporated Nonprofit Association)
Sue Lehman
Fostoria Competition Cheer, Corporation – Mar 12, 2025 (Non-Profit Corp)


First Baptist Church of Fostoria – Sep 11, 2023 (Non-Profit Corp)
Fostoria District Office Coffee Club – Feb 15, 2022 (Non-Profit Corp)
Fostoria Bascom Right to Life Education Inc. – Nov 17, 2021 (Non-Profit Corp)
Fostoria Bascom Area Prolife – Jan 29, 2018 (Non-Profit Corp)
Bethel Baptist Church of Fostoria – Dec 31, 2012 (Non-Profit Corp)
Fostoria Community Band – Aug 29, 2006 (Non-Profit Corp)
Fostoria Church of God – Jun 02, 2005 (Church)
Daybreak of Fostoria, Inc. – Dec 21, 1999 (Non-Profit Corp)

Source: Ohio Business Services Portal