FOSTORIA | Lawsuit Pending Over Fire-Chief-Root’s Selective Enforcement Practices
Published by The Associates, The Fostoria Free Press
Fostoria, Ohio (The Fostoria Free Press) – Amid breaking the initial story on this matter last week, new information has been coming into the press room. This development aligns with broader accusations against Chief Root, who is reportedly training a successor and preparing to step down amid ongoing claims of unethical behavior and selective enforcement. Multiple business owners have alleged that Root previously gave informal permission to operate without full permits, only to later pursue enforcement actions against disfavored properties.
Local business owner Randy Cunningham, who owns the property at 304 N. Main Street, says the building has been effectively frozen by conflicting directives from city officials.
![]()
Cunningham claims a previous city compliance officer approved renting the high-end apartments, including to two single mothers. However, he received a citation from Chief Root giving him just 48 hours to remove the tenants. Despite the county auditor classifying the building as a duplex (residential), Cunningham says Root has blocked all use of the property — even basic storage improvements like installing a 2×4.
“My attorney told me to comply and we’d take it to court,” Cunningham said. “This building is in compliance with the county, but according to Root I can’t do anything with it. I’m still paying property taxes on a property I can’t rent or use.”
Cunningham says he has already sold $1.3 million in other investments to exit Fostoria, but the 304 N. Main property remains unsellable due to the restrictions.
A public records request filed earlier this year by The Fostoria Free Press highlighted inconsistencies in how building inspections and code enforcement are handled. Root’s office has claimed the Fire Department lacks authority over building inspections, a statement some view as inconsistent with reported enforcement actions.
The situation has left some property owners feeling targeted, with little oversight from other city departments. Cunningham says he filed the federal lawsuit because “this needs to stop.”
The Fostoria Free Press will continue to follow both the 304NMain LLC case and any additional developments regarding Chief Root’s reported departure and the city’s code enforcement practices. Soon I will be highlighting the factual evidence of inspection negligence leading to serious overlooking illegal practices at a large commercial property in Fostoria.
Have you experienced issues with code enforcement in Fostoria? Share your thoughts below (civilly).
This article is based on court records and statements from involved parties.