Ohio Agrees to $10.2 Million in Settlements for Five Toledo Men Wrongfully Imprisoned in 1992 Killing
![]()
File photo: The Lucas County Courthouse in Toledo. (Photo: Kevinmarsh / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
TOLEDO, Ohio — The state of Ohio has agreed to settlements totaling $10.2 million for five men who spent decades in prison for the 1992 killing of Vernon Huggins in Toledo’s Wilson Park, convictions that were later thrown out, according to court filings reported Wednesday by WTOL 11 and 13 Action News.
Under the proposed agreements, Eric Misch, Louis “Louie” Costilla Jr. and Joseph Rickard would each receive $2.9 million, a combined $8.7 million. Brothers Ismael “Mel” Vasquez and Lorenzo Vasquez would each receive $750,000. The settlements are not yet final.
Declared ‘wrongfully imprisoned individuals’
In Lucas County Common Pleas Court filings dated Monday, Nov. 16, all five men were declared “wrongfully imprisoned individuals” under Ohio law, 13 Action News reported. That declaration is the step that allows a person to seek compensation from the state through the Ohio Court of Claims.
According to 13 Action News, Judge Ian English signed the declaration for the Vasquez brothers, and Judge Stacy Cook signed the filing covering Costilla, Misch and Rickard. The judgment for the brothers says they and the state have reached a settlement and plan to file it in the Ohio Court of Claims.
A settlement agreement attached to the filing for Costilla, Misch and Rickard says it is not binding until it is approved by the Ohio attorney general, the Ohio Court of Claims and the Ohio Controlling Board, the station reported. Court documents reviewed by 13 Action News say the Vasquez brothers’ $750,000 settlements must still be approved by the Ohio attorney general. WTOL reported the payments would be made if the state grants final approval. Neither report explained the difference in the amounts.
Kay Anderson of the Northwest Ohio Innocence Clinic told 13 Action News the declaration is the first of its kind in Lucas County.
The 1992 case
Huggins, 31, was found beaten to death in Wilson Park on Aug. 4, 1992, according to WTOL and the National Registry of Exonerations. The five men were sent to prison in 1993. Misch, Rickard and Costilla were convicted at trial, and the Vasquez brothers entered Alford pleas, which allowed them to maintain their innocence, after their three friends were found guilty, WTOL reported.
Prosecutors at the time said the men belonged to a street gang called the Bishops and targeted Huggins. Misch was 16 when he gave police a confession. He later told WTOL’s 11 Investigates he had nothing to do with the crime and was pressured by detectives. Each of the five men has consistently denied any involvement, WTOL reported.
Evidence that was never turned over
Years of public records requests by the Ohio Public Defender’s Wrongful Conviction Project turned up Toledo police records that had never been given to defense attorneys or, according to WTOL, even to the prosecutor’s office. Those records included Crime Stoppers tips pointing to other possible suspects. A 2022 DNA test on a bottle found near Huggins’ body also produced the name of another possible suspect, WTOL reported. 13 Action News reported that testing found Huggins’ blood on a broken beer bottle and another man’s DNA on its mouth. No one else has been charged.
“The evidence showed that at times when the people the state was pursuing were supposedly in the park, murdering this man, there were people, five miles away, his family, who were interacting with him,” attorney Tim Sweeney said last year, according to 13 Action News.
In May 2024, Common Pleas Judge Gary Cook granted Misch a new trial, and prosecutors dismissed his case in November 2024, making him the first person exonerated of a murder in Lucas County, WTOL reported. Judge Joseph McNamara then vacated the convictions of Rickard, Costilla and the Vasquez brothers in December 2024, and all charges against them were dismissed on Jan. 3, 2025. Ismael Vasquez, the only one of the five still in prison, was released that day.
The Lucas County Prosecutor’s Office has said in court filings that dismissing the charges did not mean it believed the men were innocent, citing Misch’s confession, the death of the lead detective and witnesses who could no longer be reached or would not cooperate, WTOL reported in January 2025. The office has also said it did not have the undisclosed evidence either, according to 13 Action News.
Decades behind bars
Each of the five men spent at least 20 years in prison, WTOL reported. According to 13 Action News, Ismael Vasquez spent 32 years in prison in connection with the case, and his older brother, Lorenzo, spent 22 years.
“It’s a little difficult, ’cause I got locked up, like I said, I was 16 years old,” Ismael Vasquez told 13 Action News.
“If all this evidence had been available to us, we would have never got convicted,” Lorenzo Vasquez said.
Ohio pays nearly $69,000 for each year of wrongful imprisonment, plus lost wages, WTOL reported in May. The five men also filed a separate federal lawsuit against the city of Toledo and more than a dozen former officers and detectives, according to WTOL. Wednesday’s reports on the state settlements did not address that case.
Sources: WTOL 11 (reporting by 11 Investigates Lead Investigator Brian Dugger); 13 Action News (WTVG); National Registry of Exonerations.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!