These 10 business ideas blend local charm with modern demands to boost foot traffic, create jobs, and foster a vibrant community hub.
1. Year-Round Coffee Shop and Roaster
Capitalize on Fostoria’s growing downtown scene by opening a year-round coffee shop that doubles as an on-site roaster. Sourcing beans from global origins and roasting them fresh would attract caffeine enthusiasts seeking unique blends, while offering cozy seating, Wi-Fi, and local events like open mics could make it a community staple. With existing coffee spots proving successful, this venture could enhance morning commutes and evening gatherings, drawing in residents and visitors alike.
2. Cannabis Dispensary
Following Ohio’s recent cannabis law updates on December 19, 2025, which direct 36% of excise tax revenue to host municipalities like Fostoria, a licensed dispensary could thrive on Main Street. Focusing on recreational and medicinal products with educational sessions on safe use, it would tap into the state’s booming market while contributing significant local funds for infrastructure. Emphasizing discreet, professional operations would align with community values and boost economic growth.
3. Smoke Shop
A modern smoke shop offering premium cigars, vaping supplies, and accessories could fill a retail gap, as discussed in local debates about such businesses on Main Street. By incorporating lounge areas for tastings and partnering with nearby events, it would cater to adults seeking relaxation options, potentially increasing evening foot traffic and complementing Fostoria’s revitalization by occupying vacant storefronts.
4. Bakery
Introduce a artisanal bakery specializing in fresh breads, pastries, and custom cakes, using local ingredients to evoke Fostoria’s hometown feel. Morning rushes for coffee and donuts, combined with afternoon treats, would draw families and workers. Hosting baking classes or pop-up markets could integrate it into community events, supporting the area’s push for more retail and enhancing the sensory appeal of Main Street.
5. Italian Restaurant
An authentic Italian restaurant featuring homemade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and regional wines would bring a touch of European flair to Fostoria. With family-style dining and outdoor seating for warmer months, it could become a go-to spot for date nights and celebrations. Leveraging the city’s parade and festival traditions, themed events like Italian nights could boost tourism and fill a dining niche in the downtown landscape.
6. Art Gallery and Studio
Celebrate Fostoria’s artistic side with a gallery showcasing local painters, sculptors, and photographers, complete with studio space for workshops. Rotating exhibits and art classes could engage the community, tying into the city’s cultural events and drawing crowds during holidays. This idea supports revitalization by transforming empty buildings into creative hubs, fostering a bohemian vibe on Main Street.
7. Boutique Gift Shop
A curated boutique offering unique gifts, handmade crafts, and Fostoria-themed souvenirs would appeal to shoppers seeking one-of-a-kind items. Stocking local artisan goods and seasonal decor could capitalize on parades and markets, encouraging impulse buys and repeat visits. This low-overhead business would help fill retail voids, promoting small-town charm and economic circulation within the community.
8. Cider Brewery
Establish a microbrewery with a taproom serving small-batch ciders inspired by Ohio’s heritage, such as glass-themed labels nodding to Fostoria’s history. Live music nights and food truck collaborations could turn it into a social hotspot, attracting weekend crowds and events. With the downtown’s event campus potential, it would enhance nightlife and contribute to the area’s innovation-driven growth.
9. Fitness and Yoga Studio
A wellness-focused studio offering yoga, pilates, and group fitness classes would cater to health-conscious residents amid rising interest in self-care. Affordable memberships and community challenges could build loyalty, while partnering with local businesses for wellness events aligns with revitalization goals. This active space would invigorate Main Street, promoting physical and mental health in a welcoming environment.
10. Antique and Glass Collectibles Shop
Honoring Fostoria’s legacy as the home of the Fostoria Glass Company, an antique shop specializing in vintage glassware, furniture, and collectibles would attract collectors and tourists. Appraisal events and restoration services could add value, drawing visitors interested in history. This niche business would preserve local heritage while occupying historic buildings, aiding in the overall downtown comeback.
These ideas not only address current vacancies but also leverage Fostoria’s strengths in community engagement and economic development. Entrepreneurs should connect with the Fostoria Chamber of Commerce for support, as the city’s upswing promises a fertile ground for success. Whether through food, wellness, or culture, investing in Main Street could transform Fostoria into a thriving destination.