TOLEDO | House District 44 Still Too Close to Call as Ballot Fight and Recount Loom
![]()
The Ohio Statehouse in Columbus, seen from High Street. Photo: General Ization / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0).
TOLEDO, Ohio — Two weeks after Election Day, the race for Ohio House District 44 remains too close to call, with Republican Edward Schimmel leading Democrat David Fournier by a few dozen votes, a legal challenge pending over provisional ballots, and an automatic recount possible once the results are certified.
The district takes in the western part of Lucas County, the northern section of Wood County and a western section of Ottawa County. The seat is open because Republican Josh Williams vacated it, according to the Port Clinton News Herald.
In unofficial totals reported after Election Day, Schimmel had 26,612 votes to Fournier’s 26,556, a margin of 56 votes, while independent candidate Lyndsey Stough received 2,313. After Wood County’s official canvass, announced Wednesday, Nov. 18, Schimmel’s lead stood at 36 votes, 13abc reported. Tallies circulating with that canvass put Schimmel at 26,674 and Fournier at 26,638, with Stough at 2,318. Ottawa County has certified its count. Lucas County is still completing its official canvass, which is due before the Nov. 24 state deadline. Until certification is complete, no recount has been ordered.
Lucas County Board of Elections Director LaVera Scott told the News Herald that the margin is within the 0.5% threshold that automatically triggers a recount under Ohio law.
Schimmel, through the Cincinnati-based Taft Law Firm, has also challenged some provisional ballots. The firm sent Lucas County a letter dated Nov. 15 demanding that the board reject provisional ballots cast at polling places by voters who had moved from another Ohio county, according to reporting cited by Democracy Docket. The firm argued that Ohio law required those voters to cast their provisional ballots at a board of elections office instead.
Schimmel sued the Lucas County board in the Ohio Supreme Court on Monday, in State ex rel. Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections, No. 2026-1574, The Lake Erie Inquiry reported. He asked the court to keep sealed provisional ballots cast at neighborhood polling places by voters who moved to Lucas County from other Ohio counties without updating their registration. In a sworn statement, he said there were more than 56 such ballots, more than his election-night lead. On Tuesday the court took the case off its fast track for election disputes, treated it as a standard case and ordered the board to respond to the complaint and to his request for quick action by 4 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, the Inquiry reported.
The board has said it is following Secretary of State Frank LaRose’s Election Official Manual. Deputy Director Tim Monaco told the Inquiry the board voted Monday “to proceed with the provisional ballots according to the SOS’ Election Official Manual and normal practice.” He also said the board does not keep a tally of which provisional ballots came from people who moved in from other counties. The Ohio League of Women Voters and the ACLU of Ohio have asked county boards to disregard requests to reject those ballots, noting that LaRose’s guidance told election officials that voters who moved within Ohio could cast provisional ballots at polling locations.
On Monday the Lucas board approved 1,540 provisional ballots cast on Election Day and 835 cast before Election Day, according to reporting cited by Democracy Docket. The Blade, as cited by the Inquiry, reported that the board approved more than 2,400 provisional ballots and rejected more than 600. Eight additional ballots cast at Beverly Elementary after a judge kept the polls open late following a bomb threat remain set aside until a Nov. 23 hearing, the Inquiry reported. The Lucas board was scheduled to meet at 3 p.m. Wednesday.
Until the official canvass is finished and the court case is resolved, the District 44 race remains undecided.
Sources: WTVG 13abc (updated Nov. 18, 2026); The Lake Erie Inquiry (Nov. 18, 2026); Supreme Court of Ohio, State ex rel. Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections, No. 2026-1574; Port Clinton News Herald, unofficial totals; reporting cited by Democracy Docket and ToledoBuzz.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!